Colloidal Nanoparticles of High Entropy Materials: Capabilities, Challenges, and Opportunities in Synthesis and Characterization.

Materials referred to as "high entropy" contain a large number of elements randomly distributed on the lattice sites of a crystalline solid, such that a high configurational entropy is presumed to contribute significantly to their formation and stability. High temperatures are typically required to achieve entropy stabilization, which can make it challenging to synthesize colloidal nanoparticles of high entropy materials. Nonetheless, strategies are emerging for the synthesis of colloidal high entropy nanoparticles, which are of interest for their synergistic properties and unique catalytic functions that arise from the large number of constituent elements and their interactions. In this Perspective, we highlight the classes of materials that have been made as colloidal high entropy nanoparticles as well as insights into the synthetic methods and the pathways by which they form. We then discuss the concept of "high entropy" within the context of colloidal materials synthesized at much lower temperatures than are typically required for entropy to drive their formation. Next, we identify and address challenges and opportunities in the field of high entropy nanoparticle synthesis. We emphasize aspects of materials characterization that are especially important to consider for nanoparticles of high entropy materials, including powder X-ray diffraction and elemental mapping with scanning transmission electron microscopy, which are among the most commonly used techniques in laboratory settings. Finally, we share perspectives on emerging opportunities and future directions involving colloidal nanoparticles of high entropy materials, with an emphasis on synthesis, characterization, and fundamental knowledge that is needed for anticipated advances in key application areas.

Temperature-Dependent Selection of Reaction Pathways, Reactive Species, and Products during Postsynthetic Selenization of Copper Sulfide Nanoparticles.

Rational design of elaborate, multicomponent nanomaterials is important for the development of many technologies such as optoelectronic devices, photocatalysts, and ion batteries. Combination of metal chalcogenides with different anions, such as in CdS/CdSe structures, is particularly effective for creating heterojunctions with valence band offsets. Seeded growth, often coupled with cation exchange, is commonly used to create various core/shell, dot-in-rod, or multipod geometries. To augment this library of multichalcogenide structures with new geometries, we have developed a method for postsynthetic transformation of copper sulfide nanorods into several different classes of nanoheterostructures containing both copper sulfide and copper selenide. Two distinct temperature-dependent pathways allow us to select from several outcomes-rectangular, faceted Cu2-xS/Cu2-xSe core/shell structures, nanorhombuses with a Cu2-xS core, and triangular deposits of Cu2-xSe or Cu2-x(S,Se) solid solutions. These different outcomes arise due to the evolution of the molecular components in solution. At lower temperatures, slow Cu2-xS dissolution leads to concerted morphology change and Cu2-xSe deposition, while Se-anion exchange dominates at higher temperatures. We present detailed characterization of these Cu2-xS-Cu2-xSe nanoheterostructures by transmission electron microscopy (TEM), powder X-ray diffraction, energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy, and scanning TEM-energy-dispersive spectroscopy. Furthermore, we correlate the selenium species present in solution with the roles they play in the temperature dependence of nanoheterostructure formation by comparing the outcomes of the established reaction conditions to use of didecyl diselenide as a transformation precursor.

Soft Chemistry of Hard Materials: Low-Temperature Pathways to Bulk and Nanostructured Layered Metal Borides.

Conspectus"Synthesis by design" is often considered to be the primary goal of chemists who make molecules and materials. Synthetic chemists usually have in mind a target they want to make, and they want to be able to design a pathway that can get them to that target as quickly and efficiently as possible. Chemists who synthesize refractory solids, which have melting points above 1000 °C and are often chemically inert at these high temperatures, have access to only a small number of synthetic strategies due to the need to overcome solid-state diffusion, which is the rate-limiting step in such reactions. The use of extremely high temperatures to facilitate diffusion among two or more refractory solids, which precedes any chemical reaction that must occur, generally drives the system to form only the product that is the most thermodynamically stable-the global minimum on an energy landscape-for a certain combination of elements. When trying to target a different product in the same system, one generally cannot rely on thermally driven reactions. Lower-temperature reactions that side step this diffusion limitation can succeed where high temperatures fail by providing access to local minima on an energy landscape. These local minima represent metastable phases that are primed for synthesis, but only if an appropriate pathway and set of reactions can be identified. It is therefore important to develop and understand low-temperature, or "soft", chemical reactions in "hard" refractory systems. These reactions allow us to apply the retrosynthetic framework that molecular chemists rely on to systems where chemists have not previously had such control over reactions, reactivities, and metastable product formation.In this Account, we discuss the development of soft chemical reactions of hard materials in the context of a class of layered, refractory metal borides that are precursors to an emerging family of two-dimensional nanomaterials. Layered ternary metal boride phases such as MoAlB have layers of metal borides, which are chemically unreactive, interleaved with layers of aluminum, which are reactive. Some of the interlayer aluminum can be deintercalated at room temperature in dilute aqueous sodium hydroxide, transforming stable MoAlB into destabilized MoAl1-xB. Mild thermal treatment of submicrometer grains of this destabilized MoAl1-xB sample allows it to traverse the energy landscape and crystallize as Mo2AlB2, a metastable compound. Further thermal treatment transforms Mo2AlB2 into a Mo2AlB2-alumina nanolaminate and ultimately mesoporous MoB, all through continued traversing of the energy landscape using mild chemical and thermal treatments. Similar topochemical manipulations, which maintain structure but change composition, are emerging for other MAB phases and are opening the door to new types of metastable compounds and nanostructured materials in traditionally refractory systems.

Thermally Induced Domain Migration and Interfacial Restructuring in Cation Exchanged ZnS-Cu1.8S Heterostructured Nanorods.

Partial cation exchange reactions can be used to rationally design and synthesize heterostructured nanoparticles that are useful targets for applications in photocatalysis, nanophotonics, thermoelectrics, and medicine. Such reactions introduce intraparticle frameworks that define the spatial arrangements of different materials within a heterostructured nanoparticle, as well as the orientations and locations of their interfaces. Here, we show that upon heating to temperatures relevant to their synthesis and applications, the ZnS regions and Cu1.8S/ZnS interfaces of heterostructured ZnS-Cu1.8S nanorods migrate and restructure. We first use partial cation exchange reactions to synthesize a library of seven distinct samples containing various patches, bands, and tips of ZnS embedded within Cu1.8S nanorods. Upon annealing in solution or in air, ex situ TEM analysis shows evidence that the ZnS domains migrate in different ways, depending upon their sizes and locations. Using differential scanning calorimetry, we correlate the threshold temperature for ZnS migration to the superionic transition temperature of Cu1.8S, which facilitates rapid diffusion throughout the nanorods. We then use in situ thermal TEM to study the evolution of individual ZnS-Cu1.8S nanorods upon heating. We find that ZnS domain migration occurs through a ripening process that minimizes small patches with higher-energy interfaces in favor of larger bands and tips having lower-energy interfaces, as well as through restructuring of higher-energy Cu1.8S/ZnS interfaces. Notably, Cu1.8S nanorods containing multiple patches of ZnS thermally transform into ZnS-Cu1.8S heterostructured nanorods having ZnS tips and/or central bands, which provides mechanistic insights into how these commonly observed products form during synthesis.

High Entropy Sulfide Nanoparticles as Lithium Polysulfide Redox Catalysts.

The polysulfide shuttle contributes to capacity loss in lithium-sulfur batteries, which limits their practical utilization. Materials that catalyze the complex redox reactions responsible for the polysulfide shuttle are emerging, but foundational knowledge that enables catalyst development remains limited with only a small number of catalysts identified. Here, we employ a rigorous electrochemical approach to show quantitatively that the lithium polysulfide redox reaction is catalyzed by nanoparticles of a high entropy sulfide material, Zn0.30Co0.31Cu0.19In0.13Ga0.06S. When 2% by weight of the high entropy sulfide is added to the lithium sulfur cathode composite, the capacity and Coulombic efficiency of the resulting battery are improved at both moderate (0.2 C) and high (1 C) charge/discharge rates. Surface analysis of the high entropy sulfide nanoparticles using X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy provides important insights into how the material evolves during the cycling process. The Zn0.30Co0.31Cu0.19In0.13Ga0.06S nanoparticle catalyst outperformed the constituent metal sulfides, pointing to the role that the high-entropy "cocktail effect" can play in the development of advanced electrocatalytic materials for improved lithium sulfur battery performance.

Unexpected Multi-Step Transformation of AgCuS to AgAuS During Nanoparticle Cation Exchange.

Cation exchange reactions can modify the compositions of colloidal nanoparticles, providing easy access to compounds or nanoparticles that may not be accessible directly. The most common nanoparticle cation exchange reactions replace monovalent cations with divalent cations or vice versa, but some monovalent-to-monovalent exchanges have been reported. Here, we dissect the reaction of as-synthesized AgCuS nanocrystals with Au+ to form AgAuS, initially hypothesizing that Au+ could be selective for Cu+ (rather than for Ag+) based on a known Au+-for-Cu+ exchange and the stability of the targeted AgAuS product. Unexpectedly, we found this system and the putative cation exchange reaction to be much more complex than anticipated. First, the starting AgCuS nanoparticles, which match literature reports, are more accurately described as a hybrid of Ag and a variant of AgCuS that is structurally related to mckinstryite Ag5Cu3S4. Second, the initial reaction of Ag-AgCuS with Au+ results in a galvanic replacement to transform the Ag component to a AuyAg1-y alloy. Third, continued reaction with Au+ initiates cation exchange with Cu+ in AuyAg1-y-AgCuS to form AuyAg1-y-Ag3CuxAu1-xS2 and then AuyAg1-y-AgAuS, which is the final product. Crystal structure relationships among mckinstryite-type AgCuS, Ag3CuxAu1-xS2, and AgAuS help to rationalize the transformation pathway. These insights into the reaction of AgCuS with Au+ reveal the potential complexity of seemingly simple nanoparticle reactions and highlight the importance of thorough compositional, structural, and morphological characterization before, during, and after such reactions.

Temporal Evolution of Morphology, Composition, and Structure in the Formation of Colloidal High-Entropy Intermetallic Nanoparticles.

Morphology-controlled nanoparticles of high entropy intermetallic compounds are quickly becoming high-value targets for catalysis. Their ordered structures with multiple distinct crystallographic sites, coupled with the "cocktail effect" that emerges from randomly mixing a large number of elements, yield catalytic active sites capable of achieving advanced catalytic functions. Despite this growing interest, little is known about the pathways by which high entropy intermetallic nanoparticles form and grow in solution. As a result, controlling their morphology remains challenging. Here, we use the high entropy intermetallic compound (Pd,Rh,Ir,Pt)Sn, which adopts a NiAs-related crystal structure, as a model system for understanding how nanoparticle morphology, composition, and structure evolve during synthesis in solution using a slow-injection reaction. By performing a time-point study, we establish the initial formation of palladium-rich cube-like Pd-Sn seeds onto which the other metals deposit over time, concomitant with continued incorporation of tin. For (Pd,Rh,Ir,Pt)Sn, growth occurs on the corners, resulting in a sample having a mixture of flower-like and cube-like morphologies. We then synthesize and characterize a library of 14 distinct intermetallic nanoparticle systems that comprise all possible binary, ternary, and quaternary constituents of (Pd,Rh,Ir,Pt)Sn. From these studies, we correlated compositions, morphologies, and growth pathways with the constituent elements and their competitive reactivities, ultimately mapping out a framework that rationalizes the key features of the high entropy (Pd,Rh,Ir,Pt)Sn intermetallic nanoparticles based on those of their simpler constituents. We then validated these design guidelines by applying them to the synthesis of a morphologically pure variant of flowerlike (Pd,Rh,Ir,Pt)Sn particles as well as a series of (Pd,Rh,Ir,Pt)Sn particles with tunable morphologies based on control of composition.

Topochemical Anionic Subunit Insertion Reaction for Constructing Nanoparticles of Layered Oxychalcogenide Intergrowth Structures.

Intergrowth compounds contain alternating layers of chemically distinct subunits that yield composition-tunable synergistic properties. Synthesizing nanoparticles of intergrowth structures requires atomic-level intermixing of the subunits rather than segregation into stable constituent phases. Here we introduce an anionic subunit insertion reaction for nanoparticles that installs metal chalcogenide layers between metal oxide sheets. Anionic [CuS]- subunits from solution replace interlayer chloride anions from LaOCl to form LaOCuS topochemically with retention of crystal structure and morphology. Sodium acetylacetonate helps extract Cl- concomitant with the insertion of S2- and Cu+ and is generalized to other oxychalcogenides. This topochemical reaction produces nanoparticles of ordered mixed-anion intergrowth compounds and expands nanoparticle ion exchange chemistry to anionic subunits.

Synthesis and Magnetic, Optical, and Electrocatalytic Properties of High-Entropy Mixed-Metal Tungsten and Molybdenum Oxides.

High-entropy oxides (HEOs) are of interest for their unique physical and chemical properties. Significant lattice distortions, strain, and tolerance for high-vacancy concentrations set HEOs apart from single-metal or mixed-metal oxides. Herein, we synthesized and characterized the structures and compositions, along with the optical, magnetic, and electrocatalytic properties, of two families of high-entropy mixed-metal tungsten and molybdenum oxides, AWO4 and B2Mo3O8, where A and B are 3d transition metals. The HEOs A6WO4 (A = Mn, Fe, Co, Ni, Cu, and Zn) and B25Mo3O8 (B = Mn, Fe, Co, Ni, and Zn), as well as all accessible single-metal AWO4 and B2Mo3O8 parent compounds, were synthesized using high-temperature solid-state methods. X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy analysis of the surfaces revealed that the HEOs largely had the metal oxidation states expected from the bulk chemical formulas, but in some cases they were different than in the parent compounds. A6WO4 exhibited antiferromagnetic (AFM) ordering with a Néel temperature of 30 K, which is less than the average of its AFM parent compounds, and had a narrow band gap of 0.24 eV, which is much lower than all of its parent compounds. B25Mo3O8 was paramagnetic, despite the existence of AFM and ferromagnetic ordering in several of its parent compounds and had no observable band gap, which is analogous to its parent compounds. Both A6WO4 and B25Mo3O8 exhibited superior catalytic activity relative to the parent compounds for the oxygen evolution reaction, the oxidation half reaction of overall water splitting, under alkaline conditions, based on the overpotential required to reach the benchmark surface area normalized current density. Consistent with literature predictions of OER durability for ternary tungsten and molybdenum oxides, A6WO4 and B25Mo3O8 also exhibited stable performance without significant dissolution during 10 h stability experiments at a constant current.

One-step topochemical transformation of MoAlB into metastable Mo2AlB2 using a metal chloride salt reaction.

Reacting MoAlB with ZnCl2 at 550 °C produces metastable Mo2AlB2 through a one-step topochemical transformation. This reaction showcases differences in reactivity between boride-based MAB phases and carbide-based MAX phases, which are solid-state precursors to an important family of 2-D materials.

Formation and Transformation of Cu2-xSe1-yTey Nanoparticles Synthesized by Tellurium Anion Exchange of Copper Selenide.

Ion exchange reactions of colloidal nanoparticles post-synthetically modify the composition while maintaining the morphology and crystal structure and therefore are important for tuning properties and producing otherwise inaccessible and/or metastable materials. Reactions involving anion exchange of metal chalcogenides are particularly interesting, as they involve the replacement of the sublattice that defines the structure while also requiring high temperatures that can be disruptive. Here, we show that the tellurium anion exchange of weissite Cu2-xSe nanoparticles using a trioctylphosphine-tellurium complex (TOP═Te) yields weissite Cu2-xSe1-yTey solid solutions, rather than complete exchange to weissite Cu2-xTe, with compositions that are tunable based on the amount of TOP═Te used. Upon storage at room temperature in either solvent or air, tellurium-rich Cu2-xSe1-yTey solid solution nanoparticles transform, over the span of several days, to a selenium-rich Cu2-xSe1-yTey composition. The tellurium that is expelled from the solid solution during this process migrates to the surface and forms a tellurium oxide shell, which correlates with the onset of particle agglomeration due to the change in surface chemistry. Collectively, this study demonstrates tunable composition during tellurium anion exchange of copper selenide nanoparticles along with unusual post-exchange reactivity that transforms the composition, surface chemistry, and colloidal dispersibility due to the apparent metastable nature of the solid solution product.

Band Gap Narrowing in a High-Entropy Spinel Oxide Semiconductor for Enhanced Oxygen Evolution Catalysis.

High-entropy oxides (HEOs), which contain five or more metal cations that are generally thought to be randomly mixed in a crystalline oxide lattice, can exhibit unique and enhanced properties, including improved catalytic performance, due to synergistic effects. Here, we show that band gap narrowing emerges in a high-entropy aluminate spinel oxide, (Fe0.2Co0.2Ni0.2Cu0.2Zn0.2)Al2O4 (A5Al2O4). The 0.9 eV band gap of A5Al2O4 is narrower than the band gaps of all parent spinel oxides. First-principles calculations for multicomponent AAl2O4 spinels indicate that the band gap narrowing arises from the broadening of the energy distribution of the 3d states due to variations in the electronegativities and crystal field splitting across the 3d transition-metal series. As a catalyst for the oxygen evolution reaction in an alkaline electrolyte, A5Al2O4 reaches a current density of 10 mA/cm2 at an overpotential of 400 mV, outperforming all of the single-metal end members at an applied potential of 1.7 V vs RHE. Catalyst deactivation occurs after 5 h at 10 mA/cm2 and is attributed, based on elemental analysis and grazing-incidence X-ray diffraction, to the formation of a passivating layer that blocks the high-entropy oxide surface. This result helps to validate that the HEO is the active catalyst. The observation of band gap narrowing in A5Al2O4 expands the scope of synergistic properties exhibited by high-entropy materials and offers insight into the question of how the electronic structure of multicomponent oxide materials can be engineered via a high-entropy approach to achieve enhanced catalytic properties.

Chemical Insights into the Formation of Colloidal High Entropy Alloy Nanoparticles.

Nanoparticles of high entropy alloys (HEAs) have distinct properties that result from their high surface-to-volume ratios coupled with synergistic interactions among their five or more constituent elements, which are randomly distributed throughout a crystalline lattice. Methods to synthesize HEA nanoparticles are emerging, including solution approaches that yield colloidal products. However, the complex multielement compositions of HEA nanoparticles make it challenging to identify and understand their reaction chemistry and the pathways by which they form, which hinders their rational synthesis. Here, we demonstrate the synthesis and elucidate the reaction pathways of seven colloidal HEA nanoparticle systems that contain various combinations of noble metals (Pd, Pt, Rh, Ir), 3d transition metals (Ni, Fe, Co), and a p-block element (Sn). The nanoparticles were synthesized by slowly injecting a solution containing all five constituent metal salts into oleylamine and octadecene at 275 °C. Using NiPdPtRhIr as a lead system, we confirmed the homogeneous colocalization of all five elements and achieved tunable compositions by varying their ratios. We also observed heterogeneities, including Pd-rich regions, in a subpopulation of the NiPdPtRhIr sample. Halting the reaction at early time points and characterizing the isolated products revealed a time-dependent composition evolution from Pd-rich NiPd seeds to the final NiPdPtRhIr HEA. Similar reactions applied to FePdPtRhIr, CoPdPtRhIr, NiFePdPtIr, and NiFeCoPdPt, with modified conditions to most efficiently incorporate all five elements into each HEA, also revealed similar Pd-rich seeds with system-dependent differences in the rates and sequences of element uptake into the nanoparticles. When moving to SnPdPtRhIr and NiSnPdPtIr, the time-dependent formation pathway was more consistent with simultaneous coreduction rather than through formation of reactive seeds. These studies reveal important similarities and differences among the pathways by which different colloidal HEA nanoparticles form using the same synthetic method, as well as establish generality. The results provide guidelines for incorporating a range of different elements into HEA nanoparticles, ultimately providing fundamental knowledge about how to define and optimize synthetic protocols, expand into different HEA nanoparticle systems, and achieve high phase purity.

Introducing Porosity into Refractory Molybdenum Boride through Controlled Decomposition of a Metastable Mo-Al-B Precursor.

The high temperatures typically required to synthesize refractory compounds preclude the formation of high-energy morphological features, including nanoscopic pores that are beneficial for applications, such as catalysis, that require higher surface areas. Here, we demonstrate a low-temperature multistep pathway to engineer mesoporosity into a catalytic refractory material. Mesoporous molybdenum boride, α-MoB, forms through the controlled thermal decomposition of nanolaminate-containing sheets of the metastable MAB (metal-aluminum-boron) phase Mo2AlB2 and amorphous alumina. Upon heating, the Mo2AlB2 layers of the Mo2AlB2-AlOx nanolaminate, which is derived from MoAlB, begin to bridge and decompose, forming inclusions of alumina in a framework of α-MoB. The alumina can be dissolved in aqueous sodium hydroxide in an autoclave, forming α-MoB with empty and accessible pores. Statistical analysis of the morphologies and dimensions of the pores reveals a correlation with grain size, which relates to the pathway by which the alumina inclusions form. The transformation of Mo2AlB2 to α-MoB is topotactic due to crystal structure relationships, resulting in a high density of stacking faults that can be modeled to account for the observed experimental diffraction data. Porosity was validated by comparing surface areas and demonstrating catalytic viability for the hydrogen evolution reaction.